Skip to main content

Tenant Screening

We work hard to find the right tenant for your investment

Schedule a Consultation

Thorough Tenant Screening for Peace of Mind

Bainbridge Island Tenant Screening

At Puget Sound Property Management, Inc., we know the right tenant makes all the difference. While it can be tempting to prioritize speed, we focus on finding the best tenant—not just the first one.

This upfront investment in careful screening results in:

  • Fewer issues and late payments
  • Longer, more stable tenancies
  • A positive rental experience for both owners and tenants

Our Comprehensive Screening Process

We go far beyond a basic credit check. Each applicant is carefully evaluated with a holistic approach, including:

  • Credit history & score – to assess financial responsibility
  • Employment & income stability – ensuring reliable rent payments
  • Debt-to-income ratios – evaluating overall affordability
  • Prior eviction history – spotting potential red flags
  • Criminal background checks – for safety and peace of mind
  • References from previous landlords – to confirm rental history and tenant behavior

Rather than relying on a single metric, we consider the full picture to ensure your property is in reliable hands.

This thorough screening process has helped us maintain a strong track record of tenant success—protecting your investment while creating a positive rental experience.

Ready to discover your property’s potential? Call us today at 206.842.9557 or fill out the form to get your free rental analysis!

Schedule Your Free Consultation

I Am A:

Why Choose a Local Property Management Company Over Big-Box Firms?

Personalized Service

Local property managers know you and your property personally. They offer tailored solutions and direct communication, unlike big-box companies where you might get lost in a sea of clients and automated systems.

Deep Community Knowledge

A local company understands the unique nuances of your neighborhood and market—especially important in Bainbridge Island. They know the local laws, tenant demographics, and market trends better than large national firms.

Faster Response Times

When maintenance issues or tenant problems arise, a local manager can respond quickly and often in person. Big companies may rely on remote teams or third-party vendors, which can delay critical repairs or decisions.

Stronger Vendor Relationships

Local managers have established relationships with trusted local contractors and service providers, ensuring quality work at fair prices and faster turnaround times.

Greater Accountability

Your property manager lives in the same community and reputation matters. They are more invested in providing excellent service and maintaining long-term client relationships.

Flexible & Customized Solutions

Local firms can adapt their services to fit your specific needs, whereas large companies often use rigid, one-size-fits-all approaches.

Areas We Serve

Kitsap County

Pierce County

Contact Us

I Am A: